Skip to content

Fact, plan and scenario: what-if in the accounts

If you want to know what a decision means financially, you have to keep facts, plans and scenarios strictly apart. That way you can work through a scenario without changing the booked figures.

In short

A dividend payment, an investment, a different split between salary and profit: before you decide, you want to see what it does to your balance sheet, your result and your tax. You can only do that reliably if three things never get mixed up: what has been booked (the fact), what you intend to do (the plan) and what you only want to explore (the scenario).

The three layers

  • Fact. The accounts as your bookkeeper holds them. You change nothing there.
  • Plan. Measures you want to take, recorded as concrete entries that have not yet been made.
  • Scenario. A combination of plans you want to work through: "what if I pay out more dividend this year and less next year?"

Why separation matters so much

A common mistake is to put an expected entry into the figures in advance as an adjustment. That is correct until the bookkeeper actually processes the entry; then it suddenly counts twice, without anyone noticing. By keeping plans visible next to the facts, that cannot happen. And as soon as a plan has actually been booked, it disappears from the plans.

Calculating in real accounts

It works best when you work through scenarios in real accounts: a shadow copy of your books, into which planned measures are loaded as balanced journal entries. You then see the full balance sheet and profit and loss account as if the plan had already been carried out, and you can compare scenarios side by side.

What to watch out for

  • Let every scenario check itself: does the balance sheet still balance, are all entries in balance?
  • Mind the order. A payment this year affects next year's interest and tax.
  • Keep the shadow copy up to date with an internal audit and live verification against the source.
  • The outcome is a calculation aid; the decision and the advice remain with you and your adviser.

Would you like advice on scenarios in your accounting? Request a free advice conversation.

Updated on

Services

What is full stack?

Full stack means every layer of an application, from the screen to the database and the server. A full-stack developer or team works across those layers.

Services

Who holds up a mirror to your CIO?

CIOs and IT managers divide their time between budgets, suppliers, projects and people. A sparring partner with current technical knowledge makes their decisions stronger, and gives the board confidence.

Services

What is the Definition of Done?

The Definition of Done records in advance when something is really finished. That way everyone knows in advance what the delivered work will be checked against.